List of Contributions

RE: Request for comment: RSC/NARDAC/2026/X

Posted By Thumy Webb Jul 20, 2026 05:57 PM
Found In Egroup: Core CC:DA Public Space \ view thread

I support this proposal and agree with the reasoning that RDA should contain general principles and "case law" ought to be address in policy statements or community guidance. (Before this proposal I wasn't aware that these condition existed in RDA, and was surprised that something so specific was in ...

RE: Review of RSC/TranslationsTLO/2026/2 by July 3rd

Posted By Thumy Webb Jul 02, 2026 06:23 PM
Found In Egroup: Core CC:DA Public Space \ view thread

Recommendation 1 I do not support this recommendation. As Kathy pointed out, if the proposed definition was worded to accommodate EURIG's concern about being able to use "scribe agent/etc." for published reproductions/facsimiles, then nesting the term under producer agent of unpublished manifestation ...

RE: Review of RSC/TechnicalWG/2026/3

Posted By Thumy Webb May 22, 2026 06:36 PM
Found In Egroup: Core CC:DA Public Space \ view thread

I support the full deprecation of the critique/review terms, but don't agree with deprecating digest. In my understanding of the conventional definitions of digest and abridgement, A digest summarizes and organizes multiple things, which provides multiple perspectives or examples of a ...

RE: Review of RSC/ExamplesEditor/2026/1

Posted By Thumy Webb May 22, 2026 05:19 PM
Found In Egroup: Core CC:DA Public Space \ view thread

I agree with the proposed change. I'm a big fan of making documentation more consistent. Also, early printed materials were generally not issued with covers/jackets, so the revised order of the list makes a lot of sense. ------------------------------ Thumy Webb Original Cataloging Librarian ...

RE: Review of RSC/TechnicalWG/2026/4

Posted By Thumy Webb May 22, 2026 05:06 PM
Found In Egroup: Core CC:DA Public Space \ view thread

Regarding Kathy's observation about the use of "reproduced" in the definition/scope of item: on manifestation with: I wonder if it's a roundabout way of differentiating between things published (reproduced?) together vs. separate items joined together post-publication by the owner. --Thumy

RE: Proposal to add the element Format of Notated Movement

Posted By Thumy Webb Apr 14, 2026 01:25 PM
Found In Egroup: Core CC:DA Public Space \ view thread

I vote yes to approve! --Thumy

RE: Review of RSC/TranslationsTLO/2026/1

Posted By Thumy Webb Mar 19, 2026 02:58 PM
Found In Egroup: Core CC:DA Public Space \ view thread

I generally support this proposal but have comments: Compositor agent I'm not sure about the term coherent layout in the proposed definition. Would a compositor for a layout that is purposely incoherent be excluded? I don't think the definition would suffer if coherent was removed: "An agent who ...

RE: Review of RSC/TechnicalWG/2026/2

Posted By Thumy Webb Mar 19, 2026 01:27 PM
Found In Egroup: Core CC:DA Public Space \ view thread

I support this proposal. ------------------------------ Thumy Webb Original Cataloging Librarian Rice University, Houston TX ------------------------------

RE: Review of RSC/TechnicalWG/2026/1

Posted By Thumy Webb Mar 19, 2026 01:21 PM
Found In Egroup: Core CC:DA Public Space \ view thread

I support this proposal. ------------------------------ Thumy Webb Original Cataloging Librarian Rice University, Houston TX ------------------------------

RE: Updated document from Compound Surnames TF - Clarify instructions for surnames with an initialized part

Posted By Thumy Webb Feb 25, 2026 01:52 PM
Found In Egroup: Core CC:DA Public Space \ view thread

I vote yes to approve! --Thumy

RE: Call for a vote on CC:DA Taskforce to Propose Familial Relationship Elements for RDA

Posted By Thumy Webb Feb 16, 2026 02:57 PM
Found In Egroup: Core CC:DA Public Space \ view thread

I vote FOR the motion to accept the proposal submitted by the CC:DA Taskforce to Propose Familial Relationship Elements for RDA as amended in its latest version. ------------------------------ Thumy Webb Original Cataloging Librarian Rice University, Houston TX ----------------------------- ...

RE: Request for Comment: Proposal for Manifestation: Extent of Aggregated Content

Posted By Thumy Webb Dec 22, 2025 02:39 PM
Found In Egroup: Core CC:DA Public Space \ view thread

Recommendation 2: In the section that says "Record an appropriate term from the RDA Illustrative Content vocabulary encoding scheme: illustration" it would be helpful to include the instruction "Record the term in the singular or plural, as applicable" unless plural is not allowed. Recommendation ...

RE: Request for Comment: Proposal for Manifestation: Sequence of Units of Extent

Posted By Thumy Webb Dec 12, 2025 12:40 PM
Found In Egroup: Core CC:DA Public Space \ view thread

Hi all, I have a suggestion and a question and would appreciate your feedback. Suggestion:The proposed definition of the proposed element uses the term "unit" but I wonder if "subunit" should be incorporated in the definition somehow to make it more consistent with how unit/subunits are used in the ...

RE: RSC Religion Working Group Seeking Feedback on Proposal

Posted By Thumy Webb Sep 30, 2025 02:04 PM
Found In Egroup: Core CC:DA Public Space \ view thread

Hi all, I just wanted to confirm that only Recommendation 1 in the RSC Religions Working Group 2025/1 document is a new change, and that Recommendation 2 is a duplicate of what was already approved and implemented from 2024/2. Is that correct? If so, my only comment is that there are grammatical errors ...

Divisions

Round Tables