Thanks so much, Martin, for the update!
Elaine
> Hi all,
>
> 12 of the 14 interpretations passed, but "Economic Barriers to Library
> Access" and "Access to Resources and Services in the School Library" were
> sent back to the IFC for further revision. I've attached the IFC report
> with the (now approved) interpretations in case you haven't seen them.
>
> There will be another batch coming next month at the Annual Conference,
> then that should be it for this round -- they need to finish the
> manuscript
> in July in order for the next edition of the Intellectual Freedom Manual
> to
> be published in time.
>
> Best,
>
> Martin
>
> On Fri, May 30, 2025 at 9:16 AM Elaine Harger <
eharger@drizzle.com> wrote:
>
>> Dear Al and all,
>>
>> Thanks so much, Al, for bringing this to my attention. I wholeheartedly
>> agree with you that SRRT and ALA should certainly act to support
>> protesters' rights and that failing to do so counts against the record
>> this interpretation eloquently proclaims.
>>
>> Did the interpretations pass yesterday?
>>
>> Elaine
>>
>>
>>
>> > Good morning all,
>> >
>> > Thanks to Lisa Gieskes for sending the proposed new interpretations of
>> the
>> > Library Bill of Rights, to be voted by the ALA Council in a special
>> > session on May 29th. I want to bring your attention to the following
>> > interpretation on free expression that appears as Appendix 5. I have
>> > highlighted a number of parts below in red to bring them to your
>> > attention. In this document ALA will declare that it is "deeply
>> committed
>> > to human rights,” and that "Everyone has the right to freedom of
>> peaceful
>> > assembly and association.” It declares that "Throughout history,
>> > courageous people have defended the right to speak freely, even when
>> faced
>> > with threats, slavery, captivity, torture, exile, and death. Their
>> actions
>> > demonstrate that free expression is a basic human right and that it
>> > demands justice. Their bravery inspires ALA.”
>> >
>> > So as I have argued for at least a year and a half, ALA is a civil
>> > liberties organization. The interpretation goes further and declares
>> that
>> > ALA is “deeply committed to human rights.” The document does not
>> > distinguish between human rights that are directly related to
>> libraries
>> > and human rights that are denied outside of libraries in the broader
>> > society. That means that the IRTF resolution on protecting freedom of
>> > speech and assembly for peaceful protesters against genocide in Gaza
>> is
>> > certainly within the framework of ALA’s policy agenda.
>> >
>> > That means that the SRRT Action Council’s reluctance to address this
>> > fundamental right by a resolution to the ALA Council is wrongheaded
>> and
>> > has no real justification, except for the supposition that the
>> resolution
>> > might fail. Being afraid to put something forward to the ALA Council
>> > because it might fail is a defeatist attitude. It is against almost
>> all
>> of
>> > SRRT’s history. If even SRRT can’t take a brave stand on behalf of
>> core
>> > principles, how can we even justify our round table's existence? This
>> > country is well on its way to fascism, and we need every organization
>> > possible to stand up for democracy and the Bill of Rights. ALA can be
>> an
>> > important voice in coalition with other civil liberties and human
>> rights
>> > organizations. We need to be much braver! Further, our silence will
>> only
>> > embolden the fascists. It is foolish to only promote First Amendment
>> > principles inside libraries and let those same principles be denied
>> > outside in society.
>> >
>> > Thanks for reading this, and for thinking again about SRRT’s role
>> within
>> > ALA, the LIS profession, and the country.
>> >
>> > Al
>> >
>> > Al Kagan
>> > SRRT International Responsibilities Task Force
>> > SRRT Councilor, 1999-2009, 2011-2015
>> >
>> > African Studies Bibliographer and Professor of Library Administration
>> > Emeritus
>> > University of Illinois Urbana/Champaign
>> >
>> >
>> >
>> >
>> > ACTION ITEM: The Intellectual Freedom Committee moves the adoption of
>> the
>> > following action
>> >
>> > item: “The Universal Right to Free Expression: An Interpretation of
>> the
>> > Library Bill of Rights”
>> >
>> >
>> > The Universal Right to Free Expression
>> >
>> > Freedom of expression is a basic human right and the foundation for
>> > self-government. It includes the right
>> >
>> > to free speech, press, religion, assembly, and association. It also
>> means
>> > having the right to receive
>> >
>> > information without interference and to keep personal information
>> > private.
>> >
>> >
>> > The American Library Association (ALA) endorses this principle. It is
>> also
>> > in the Universal Declaration of
>> >
>> > Human Rights, adopted by the United Nations General Assembly1. The
>> > preamble states that:
>> >
>> > . . . recognition of the inherent dignity and of the equal and
>> inalienable
>> > rights of all members of the
>> >
>> > human family is the foundation of freedom, justice, and peace in the
>> > world. . . [and] . . . the advent
>> >
>> > of a world in which human beings shall enjoy freedom of speech and
>> belief
>> > and freedom from fear
>> >
>> > and want has been proclaimed as the highest aspiration of the common
>> > people. . . .
>> >
>> >
>> > Article 12 of this document states:
>> >
>> > No one shall be subjected to arbitrary interference with his privacy,
>> > family, home or
>> >
>> > correspondence, nor to attacks upon his honor or reputation. Everyone
>> has
>> > the right to the
>> >
>> > protection of the law against such interference or attacks.
>> >
>> >
>> > Article 18 states:
>> >
>> > Everyone has the right to freedom of thought, conscience and religion;
>> > this right includes freedom
>> >
>> > to change his religion or belief, and freedom, either alone or in
>> > community with others and in public
>> >
>> > or private, to manifest his religion or belief in teaching, practice,
>> > worship and observance.
>> >
>> > Article 19 states:
>> >
>> >
>> > Everyone has the right to freedom of opinion and expression; this
>> right
>> > includes freedom to hold
>> >
>> > opinions without interference and to seek, receive and impart
>> information
>> > and ideas through any
>> >
>> > media regardless of frontiers.
>> >
>> >
>> > Article 20 states:
>> >
>> > 1. 2. Everyone has the right to freedom of peaceful assembly and
>> > association.
>> >
>> > No one may be compelled to belong to an association.
>> >
>> >
>> > In 2013, the UN General Assembly reaffirmed that the right to privacy
>> > applies to digital communications
>> >
>> > and records. They require governments of member nations to “respect
>> and
>> > protect” peoples’ privacy
>> >
>> > rights.
>> >
>> >
>> > The ALA believes that every person has these rights, no matter their
>> > origin, age, background, or views. The
>> >
>> > ALA shows its commitment to these principles in the Library Bill of
>> Rights
>> > and Code of Ethics. These
>> >
>> > principles should be upheld by libraries and library workers
>> worldwide.
>> > The ALA’s “International Relations”
>> >
>> > policy reflects these objectives, “. . . to encourage the exchange,
>> > dissemination, and access to information
>> >
>> > and the unrestricted flow of library materials in all formats
>> throughout
>> > the world.”
>> >
>> >
>> > Censorship, ignorance, and manipulation are the tools used by those in
>> > power. The ALA actively supports
>> >
>> > net neutrality, transparency, and accountability. Governments and
>> > companies that block, control, or
>> >
>> > monitor personal communications without consent or oversight is unfair
>> and
>> > unjust. These same entities also collect large amounts of personal
>> > information without due process or transparency. This abuse of
>> >
>> > public trust threatens privacy and harms the right to free expression.
>> > Everyone benefits when people are
>> >
>> > treated with respect. This allows ideas and information to be freely
>> > shared, debated, and tested in the
>> >
>> > public sphere.
>> >
>> >
>> > The ALA is deeply committed to human rights, especially the rights to
>> > privacy and free expression. These
>> >
>> > rights are essential to the practice of librarianship. The rights of
>> > privacy and free expression are not tied to
>> >
>> > politics, race, economics, or culture. These rights are inherent in
>> every
>> > person. They cannot be taken away,
>> >
>> > reduced, or denied by governments or businesses. True justice and
>> equality
>> > depend on protecting and
>> >
>> > using these rights every day.
>> >
>> >
>> > Information and ideas have power. They can:
>> >
>> > • inspire justice;
>> >
>> > • restore freedom and dignity to the exploited and oppressed;
>> >
>> > • change the hearts and minds of the oppressors; and
>> >
>> > • offer opportunities for a better life to all people.
>> >
>> >
>> > Throughout history, courageous people have defended the right to speak
>> > freely, even when faced with
>> >
>> > threats, slavery, captivity, torture, exile, and death. Their actions
>> > demonstrate that free expression is a
>> >
>> > basic human right and that it demands justice. Their bravery inspires
>> ALA.
>> > Their deeds challenge library
>> >
>> > workers to stay committed to promoting and defending the rights of
>> privacy
>> > and free expression.
>> >
>> >
>> > There is no such thing as good censorship. Restricting free expression
>> and
>> > the flow of information leads to
>> >
>> > discrimination and oppression. Using censorship to fight oppression
>> only
>> > causes more harm. People can’t
>> >
>> > truly be free without personal privacy. A society that does not
>> respect
>> > personal privacy will fail to see when
>> >
>> > its rights and freedoms are taken away.
>> >
>> >
>> > Threats to the privacy and freedom of expression of any person
>> anywhere
>> > are threats to the privacy and
>> >
>> > freedom of all people everywhere. Violations of these human rights
>> have
>> > been recorded in nearly every
>> >
>> > country and society around the world. Vigilance in protecting these
>> rights
>> > is our best defense.
>> >
>> >
>> > In response to these violations, the ALA:
>> >
>> > • Opposes any government action that prevents people from exercising
>> their
>> > rights. Everyone should
>> >
>> > be free to seek, receive, and share information and ideas without
>> > interference. Libraries and library
>> >
>> > workers must actively resist these abuses and support those affected
>> by
>> > them.
>> >
>> >
>> > • Condemns any government effort to use libraries and library workers
>> to
>> > restrict people’s rights.
>> >
>> > Libraries exist to help people seek, receive, and share information
>> and
>> > ideas. Laws, contracts, or
>> >
>> > agreements that limit these rights go against the mission of
>> libraries.
>> > They also violate the
>> >
>> > professional responsibilities of library workers.
>> >
>> >
>> > • Rejects censorship in any form. Actions that deny basic human rights
>> > weakens the will to resist
>> >
>> > oppression. They also empower oppressors and undermine the cause of
>> > justice.
>> >
>> > Censorship harms justice and destroys freedom. As such, the ALA will
>> not
>> > stand down from these
>> >
>> > principles.
>> >
>> >
>> > NOTES
>> >
>> > 1. United Nations General Assembly, “Universal Declaration of Human
>> > Rights,” United Nations, December 10, 1948.
>> >
>> >
>> >
>> >
>> >
>> >
>> >
>> >
>> >
>> >
>> >
>> >
>> >
>>
>>
>> Elaine Harger
>>
>> 509-893-8862 (landline)
>> 425-221-8294 (texts)
>> eharger at drizzle dot com
>>
>> "I'd say I'm a revolutionary optimist. I believe that the good guys -
>> the
>> people - are going to win." Amiri Baraka, 1934-2014
>>
>>
>
> --
> Martin Garnar, PhD, MLIS
>
> Director of the Library
>
> Amherst College
>
> 61 Quadrangle Dr.
>
> Amherst, MA 01002
>
> he/him/his
> [image: Amherst College Bicentennial 1821-2021]
> <https: linklock.titanhq.com analyse?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.amherst.edu%2Fgo%2F200&data=eJxNi7EKwjAQQL8mGcPRWIvDDS6OToLgduSOpGCsXFIC-XrjVni84cELePbiZaHLHDyDZWRde3-LC1u2Ge_r_KjPxssLui2YI-mH1JyAchIt1QnvVlESaZR_P-47plq_xfirmW6D1po7fKPEbWgC-AENyi0n>
> [image: email]
mgarnar@amherst.edu> [image: phone] 413-542-2378
> [image: website] amherst.edu/library
> <https: linklock.titanhq.com analyse?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.amherst.edu%2Flibrary&data=eJxLtjUzTjVONU-0NE02TjFQS7FNKcqsqspJ1UvOz1XLtfXLNA0pCS9PMY8yqFIrts1NTyzKSyxSNTFIzM1ILSou0UtNKVUrsk3NSCxKTwWJI2svtc0oKSkoVjV2VDVyA6Ly8nI9JH1AkZzMpKLEokoA494uFw%%>
> [image: audio] Hear my name
> <https: linklock.titanhq.com analyse?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.name-coach.com%2Fmartin-garnar&data=eJxNjDELwjAQRn9NsjUEYy0ON7g4dhIEtyM5moCXyiUlkF9vi4vwpsf7Pg8XR44mvI7eBasDBEm9v8n4lTXDnMZHfbYwvWzXBXhBySjqbJEjSamGwqYFKKIsdPj_-Qax1k9R7qZO953WmsnINPgVfTySXTJKTXn4HX8BjHAxLg%%>
Elaine Harger
509-893-8862 (landline)
425-221-8294 (texts)
eharger at drizzle dot com
"I'd say I'm a revolutionary optimist. I believe that the good guys - the
people - are going to win." Amiri Baraka, 1934-2014
Original Message:
Sent: 5/23/2025 11:02:00 AM
From: Al Kagan
Subject: “The Universal Right to Free Expression: An Interpretation of the Library Bill of Rights”
Good morning all,
Thanks to Lisa Gieskes for sending the proposed new interpretations of the Library Bill of Rights, to be voted by the ALA Council in a special session on May 29th. I want to bring your attention to the following interpretation on free expression that appears as Appendix 5. I have highlighted a number of parts below in red to bring them to your attention. In this document ALA will declare that it is "deeply committed to human rights," and that "Everyone has the right to freedom of peaceful assembly and association." It declares that "Throughout history, courageous people have defended the right to speak freely, even when faced with threats, slavery, captivity, torture, exile, and death. Their actions demonstrate that free expression is a basic human right and that it demands justice. Their bravery inspires ALA."
So as I have argued for at least a year and a half, ALA is a civil liberties organization. The interpretation goes further and declares that ALA is "deeply committed to human rights." The document does not distinguish between human rights that are directly related to libraries and human rights that are denied outside of libraries in the broader society. That means that the IRTF resolution on protecting freedom of speech and assembly for peaceful protesters against genocide in Gaza is certainly within the framework of ALA's policy agenda.
That means that the SRRT Action Council's reluctance to address this fundamental right by a resolution to the ALA Council is wrongheaded and has no real justification, except for the supposition that the resolution might fail. Being afraid to put something forward to the ALA Council because it might fail is a defeatist attitude. It is against almost all of SRRT's history. If even SRRT can't take a brave stand on behalf of core principles, how can we even justify our round table's existence? This country is well on its way to fascism, and we need every organization possible to stand up for democracy and the Bill of Rights. ALA can be an important voice in coalition with other civil liberties and human rights organizations. We need to be much braver! Further, our silence will only embolden the fascists. It is foolish to only promote First Amendment principles inside libraries and let those same principles be denied outside in society.
Thanks for reading this, and for thinking again about SRRT's role within ALA, the LIS profession, and the country.
Al
Al Kagan
SRRT International Responsibilities Task Force
SRRT Councilor, 1999-2009, 2011-2015
African Studies Bibliographer and Professor of Library Administration Emeritus
University of Illinois Urbana/Champaign
ACTION ITEM: The Intellectual Freedom Committee moves the adoption of the following action
item: "The Universal Right to Free Expression: An Interpretation of the Library Bill of Rights"
The Universal Right to Free Expression
Freedom of expression is a basic human right and the foundation for self-government. It includes the right
to free speech, press, religion, assembly, and association. It also means having the right to receive
information without interference and to keep personal information private.
The American Library Association (ALA) endorses this principle. It is also in the Universal Declaration of
Human Rights, adopted by the United Nations General Assembly1. The preamble states that:
. . . recognition of the inherent dignity and of the equal and inalienable rights of all members of the
human family is the foundation of freedom, justice, and peace in the world. . . [and] . . . the advent
of a world in which human beings shall enjoy freedom of speech and belief and freedom from fear
and want has been proclaimed as the highest aspiration of the common people. . . .
Article 12 of this document states:
No one shall be subjected to arbitrary interference with his privacy, family, home or
correspondence, nor to attacks upon his honor or reputation. Everyone has the right to the
protection of the law against such interference or attacks.
Article 18 states:
Everyone has the right to freedom of thought, conscience and religion; this right includes freedom
to change his religion or belief, and freedom, either alone or in community with others and in public
or private, to manifest his religion or belief in teaching, practice, worship and observance.
Article 19 states:
Everyone has the right to freedom of opinion and expression; this right includes freedom to hold
opinions without interference and to seek, receive and impart information and ideas through any
media regardless of frontiers.
Article 20 states:
1. 2. Everyone has the right to freedom of peaceful assembly and association.
No one may be compelled to belong to an association.
In 2013, the UN General Assembly reaffirmed that the right to privacy applies to digital communications
and records. They require governments of member nations to "respect and protect" peoples' privacy
rights.
The ALA believes that every person has these rights, no matter their origin, age, background, or views. The
ALA shows its commitment to these principles in the Library Bill of Rights and Code of Ethics. These
principles should be upheld by libraries and library workers worldwide. The ALA's "International Relations"
policy reflects these objectives, ". . . to encourage the exchange, dissemination, and access to information
and the unrestricted flow of library materials in all formats throughout the world."
Censorship, ignorance, and manipulation are the tools used by those in power. The ALA actively supports
net neutrality, transparency, and accountability. Governments and companies that block, control, or
monitor personal communications without consent or oversight is unfair and unjust. These same entities also collect large amounts of personal information without due process or transparency. This abuse of
public trust threatens privacy and harms the right to free expression. Everyone benefits when people are
treated with respect. This allows ideas and information to be freely shared, debated, and tested in the
public sphere.
The ALA is deeply committed to human rights, especially the rights to privacy and free expression. These
rights are essential to the practice of librarianship. The rights of privacy and free expression are not tied to
politics, race, economics, or culture. These rights are inherent in every person. They cannot be taken away,
reduced, or denied by governments or businesses. True justice and equality depend on protecting and
using these rights every day.
Information and ideas have power. They can:
• inspire justice;
• restore freedom and dignity to the exploited and oppressed;
• change the hearts and minds of the oppressors; and
• offer opportunities for a better life to all people.
Throughout history, courageous people have defended the right to speak freely, even when faced with
threats, slavery, captivity, torture, exile, and death. Their actions demonstrate that free expression is a
basic human right and that it demands justice. Their bravery inspires ALA. Their deeds challenge library
workers to stay committed to promoting and defending the rights of privacy and free expression.
There is no such thing as good censorship. Restricting free expression and the flow of information leads to
discrimination and oppression. Using censorship to fight oppression only causes more harm. People can't
truly be free without personal privacy. A society that does not respect personal privacy will fail to see when
its rights and freedoms are taken away.
Threats to the privacy and freedom of expression of any person anywhere are threats to the privacy and
freedom of all people everywhere. Violations of these human rights have been recorded in nearly every
country and society around the world. Vigilance in protecting these rights is our best defense.
In response to these violations, the ALA:
• Opposes any government action that prevents people from exercising their rights. Everyone should
be free to seek, receive, and share information and ideas without interference. Libraries and library
workers must actively resist these abuses and support those affected by them.
• Condemns any government effort to use libraries and library workers to restrict people's rights.
Libraries exist to help people seek, receive, and share information and ideas. Laws, contracts, or
agreements that limit these rights go against the mission of libraries. They also violate the
professional responsibilities of library workers.
• Rejects censorship in any form. Actions that deny basic human rights weakens the will to resist
oppression. They also empower oppressors and undermine the cause of justice.
Censorship harms justice and destroys freedom. As such, the ALA will not stand down from these
principles.
NOTES
1. United Nations General Assembly, "Universal Declaration of Human Rights," United Nations, December 10, 1948.
</https:></https:></https:></eharger@drizzle.com>