Deborah, honestly, you don't have to use them. That's your choice. It doesn't mean that other libraries should be deprived of them on the basis that your state wouldn't approve. They are in line with the stated values of SRRT. Plus there is nothing that states that these are supposed to be neutral. They are offering authoritative sources for the issues at hand. Authoritative does not mean neutral. It means that the sources have the backing of appropriate evidence. It is your job as a librarian to provide balance for the issues from equally authoritative resources for the other side. It is not the job of the SRRT to provide that balance for you.
Original Message:
Sent: Jul 11, 2024 05:56 PM
From: Deborah Corbin
Subject: Pathfinders for Making Sense of Current World Events
I understand your question but I don't believe that I've ever seen us encouraged to print out flyers or brochures or leaflets to hand out to our patrons with one sided position statements. I might absolutely be wrong and please correct me if I am. Again, my problem isn't that I agree or disagree with each individual pathfinder. It's just not at all a resource for accurate representation of complex topics.
------------------------------
Deborah Corbin
Branch Assistant
York County Library
She/Her/Hers
Original Message:
Sent: Jul 11, 2024 05:47 PM
From: Rory Litwin
Subject: Pathfinders for Making Sense of Current World Events
Hi Deborah,
Couldn't the concerns you're expressing be used against anything SRRT normally does? What SRRT activities do you support?
Rory Litwin
------------------------------
Rory Litwin
President
Library Juice Academy
Original Message:
Sent: Jul 11, 2024 03:11 PM
From: Deborah Corbin
Subject: Pathfinders for Making Sense of Current World Events
Thank you, Derek, for your polite response.
In communities like ours, the ALA has been defined by the last 2 years of controversy. The perceived notion that ALA is simply a (insert label here - "woke", "Marxist", "Leftist") institution has led to a very negative backlash to our public libraries. For us to provide the Pathfinders to our communities, we would be reprimanded harshly by our governing body because we would be seen as supporting only one segment of our population. We are a government entity. We cannot provide materials which would support only one position on either side of these issues. While I am in agreement with several (not all) of the pathfinder positions on the topics, we could never allow our public library to be seen as tied to one political party or position on these issues. Book banning? Of course. Israel v Palestine, Abortion rights, etc.? Those are not themes that Joe Q. Public wishes to see promoted by the public library.
If my math is correct, roughly 1 out of 5 states have already withdrawn from ALA with several more in process. States like ours are slashing funding to libraries who do not conform to the will of the M4L, Heritage Foundation, Project 2025, Freedom Caucus, ad infinitum. Most of us "middle of the country librarians" would love to see the ALA actually showing up beside us to fight for simple freedom of information and not Global politics. We cannot continue to believe that we wield any power to global humanities if we cannot even influence our own citizens to let us check out books. As we both know, the decrease in funding has little to do with book collection but much to do with our abilities to provide all the other community resources that make our institutions so critical. If we lose the public libraries - and make no mistake, we are losing - we've lost every war.
Original Message:
Sent: 7/11/2024 3:24:00 PM
From: Derek Wilmott
Subject: RE: Pathfinders for Making Sense of Current World Events
Hi Deborah,
I am interested in what you have to say. What specifically do you find as "inappropriate" with the pathfinders? What sources would you prefer to have listed about these difficult topics?
We can talk about it on this forum or feel free to direct message me through Connect.
Sincerely,
Derek Wilmott,
SRRT Action Council Member-At-Large
Original Message:
Sent: 7/11/2024 2:52:00 PM
From: Deborah Corbin
Subject: RE: Pathfinders for Making Sense of Current World Events
I am absolutely flabbergasted. It is so interesting to me (out here in suburban South Carolina) how wholly inappropriate this would be for us. These are not fact based guides for finding accurate information about different perspectives on hot topics. Rather, in most of the US, these would be inflammatory position statements. They are absolutely one sided and not at all what I wish the ALA was promoting at this time. Printing these out or sharing with the public would destroy our libraries. The ALA needs to wake up and look at what is happening to us in public library land outside of the major metropolitan areas. If we put 1/10th of the effort into helping the massacre of public libraries in Red states as we do stoking the fire of every global conflagration, we might have a chance. Our state withdrew from ALA for this very reason. ALA did not support us in any way, shape or form when we were being trampled in America's Heartland. You are providing the ammunition that they have turned on us at every battle.
------------------------------
Deborah Corbin
Branch Assistant
York County Library
She/Her/Hers
Original Message:
Sent: Jul 09, 2024 03:55 PM
From: Frieda Afary
Subject: Pathfinders for Making Sense of Current World Events
The U.S. and the world are currently facing the challenge of misinformation, disinformation and fake news in a way that is truly endangering the future of democracies and of humanity itself. As trusted information sources, librarians have a responsibility to confront this challenge.
Guided by PEN America's media literacy guidelines, and the Poynter Institute's Be Media Wise Toolkit, the Social Responsibilities Round Table of the American Library Association has created pathfinders, each of which focus on a particular news topic.
We encourage library staff to share these beautifully designed pathfinders with the public. They can become the basis for current events discussions to promote global awareness and to facilitate a truly educational, fruitful and civil discussion, with the aim of developing creative and peaceful solutions.
|
|
Pathfinders
Trifold Pathfinders by SRRT, 2024: Abortion Banned Books Gender Gun Violence Israel and Palestine Migration Ukraine
|
|
|
Frieda Afary
Iranian American Public Librarian, Author, Translator
Los Angeles