On May 24, 2025, in a sharply divided 10–7 decision, the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that the government can restrict access to books in public libraries simply because it dislikes or disagrees with their content.
This sets an incredible precedent that will allow the state to regulate books and deny you the right to read freely in public libraries.
In this ruling, a majority of the Fifth Circuit has embraced a doctrine that not only permits but also constitutionalizes the removal of books from public libraries by government officials for ideological reasons. This is government censorship in its plainest form. The Attorneys General and other amici who advocated for a new expansive interpretation of the Government Speech Doctrine are working to extend government control over what ideas are allowed in public libraries and in schools.
https://action.everylibrary.org/bannedbooks?e=5f02daf48a680dae486ca0eeddbb2938&utm_source=votelibraries&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=govdislikes_3&n=8
------------------------------
Chip Stewart, Retired
City College of New York
he/him
------------------------------