ALA Council

 View Only
last person joined: 3 months ago 

Rules & Guidelines for ALA Hybrid Council Meetings

  • 1.  Rules & Guidelines for ALA Hybrid Council Meetings

    Posted Apr 28, 2022 05:30 PM
      |   view attached

    This message is being sent on behalf of ALA President, Patty Wong

    Dear Councilors,

    The ALA Executive Board approved the "Rules & Guidelines for ALA Hybrid Council Meetings" (ALA CD#5.2, attached) for the 2022 Annual Conference in Washington, DC. Please review in advance of the practice session that will be held at the beginning of June, date and time will be announced.  The rules will be for adoption for all hybrid Council meetings. When adopted these rules will govern the conduct of the meeting.  Council agendas and documents will be uploaded to the website and ALA Connect in advance of the meetings.

    Councilors participating in person or virtually must register for the 2022 Annual Conference, please visit: https://2022.alaannual.org/. And, for those unable to join us in Washington, DC, please register for the Digital Experience: https://2022.alaannual.org/digital-experience

    A complete list of Governance Meetings can be found, here: https://www.ala.org/aboutala/ala-governance-meetings.



    ------------------------------
    Marsha P. Burgess
    Council Secretariat
    American Library Association
    mburgess@ala.org
    (312) 280-3204
    ------------------------------


  • 2.  RE: Rules & Guidelines for ALA Hybrid Council Meetings

    Posted Apr 28, 2022 08:21 PM
    Thanks for this Marsha -- I'm concerned about the new rule about meeting attendance. The new rules read...

    Virtual Attendees must register for the ALA Conference Digital Experience and Councilors are encouraged to be in attendance at least 15 minutes prior to the start of each Council meeting to help confirm quorum.

    and

    In-person Attendees must register for the ALA Conference

    In the past, the Membership Meetings and Council Meetings were open to anyone who was an ALA member or who had an exhibits pass, and those people did not have to register for the conference. This change is substantial in terms of potential costs to people who want to be involved in governance via the Membership Meeting or Council but who would not otherwise be attending.

    I believe this is a step backwards in ALA's DEI work by creating a cost barrier to participating in ALA governance and I'm dismayed to see it as a newly created rule I do appreciate and respect that ALA has real money concerns generally and doing a hybrid conference comes with associated costs, but I do not think that this is the way forward to encourage participation and attendance at Membership/Council meetings. If there are others who feel like I do, maybe we can change this rule back to the way it was previously to encourage participation while at the same time helping ALA find a way forward dealing with its money issues.

    ------------------------------
    Jessamyn West
    Chapter Councilor - Vermont
    she/her
    ------------------------------



  • 3.  RE: Rules & Guidelines for ALA Hybrid Council Meetings

    Posted Apr 29, 2022 07:45 AM
    Thank you Jessamyn for raising these concerns.  I find several of these rules, and the overall tone of the document, problematic -- but I agree that the registration requirement is especially troublesome.   I would be happy to join you in working on alternatives for consideration.   I also think that requiring registration to participate in Council/Membership meetings is a policy issue not a rules issue and I do not recall the issue coming to Council.   Did I miss something?

    The ALA Policy Manual states (emphasis mine):
    A.7.4.5 Registration at Conferences and Midwinter Meetings (Old Number 7.4.5)
    ALA members may attend general membership and council meetings, whenever and wherever held, by showing either a conference badge for the day of the meeting or a current membership card. Registration badges shall be shown for admission to all other meetings.

    Given that Council members are members of the Association I don't understand how requiring registration to attend Council meetings is not a violation of our existing policy? 

    Eileen


    ------------------------------
    Eileen M. Palmer
    Executive Director
    LMxAC Libraries of Middlesex
    NJLA Chapter Councilor
    empalmer@lmxac.org
    ------------------------------



  • 4.  RE: Rules & Guidelines for ALA Hybrid Council Meetings

    Posted Apr 29, 2022 09:47 AM
    To be super blunt, this is kind of a garbage move. The use of virtual meeting options was finally a step in the right direction of making council more accessible to members who wanted to participate but couldn't afford to come to conferences. But now we're saying that people essentially have to spend almost $1000 a year to give ALA their unpaid labor. Be a member and pay virtual registration for two conferences a year. 

    Professional dev funds are often one of the first casualties of budget cuts and this just tells members that we don't want them participating in governance unless they meet a certain economic threshold. No one should have to pay for a conference to participate in governance. Especially not in an organization that is already struggling to keep their members engaged. 






  • 5.  RE: Rules & Guidelines for ALA Hybrid Council Meetings

    Posted Apr 29, 2022 10:10 AM
    Good morning,

    If Council is no longer a ‘policy making‘ body, as we voted on during our meeting March 2022, Council members will no longer have an option to reference policy in its new ‘advisory’ role.

    These type decisions (I.e., Rules Guidelines…) would be left to the discretion of the Executive Board: not Council.

    Correct?

    Brenda Pruitt-Annisette

    Sent from my iPhone




  • 6.  RE: Rules & Guidelines for ALA Hybrid Council Meetings

    Posted Apr 29, 2022 10:17 AM
    Not exactly. That vote was to steer the type of recommendations TAG would bring to annual. No actual change about where policy sits has been made yet (which is fortunate because it would be irresponsible to leave such an important change to one three-vote-margin motion in a not-terribly-well-attended off-cycle meeting.) If you or anyone else wants to bring something to annual regarding expectations for virtual governance going forward they can and should.





  • 7.  RE: Rules & Guidelines for ALA Hybrid Council Meetings

    Posted Apr 29, 2022 10:44 AM
    > Given that Council members are members of the Association I don't understand how requiring registration
    > to attend Council meetings is not a violation of our existing policy?

    I was confused too by the seeming conflict between the new Rules & Guidelines and ALA Policy. I saw President Wong's statement about making sure Councilors followed the policy (which I went and read) but this seems to conflict with it.

    ------------------------------
    Jessamyn West
    Chapter Councilor - Vermont
    she/her
    ------------------------------



  • 8.  RE: Rules & Guidelines for ALA Hybrid Council Meetings

    Posted Apr 29, 2022 08:06 PM

    Thank you for this discussion and the values of access and equity.  Prior to the pandemic, in-person attendance and conference registration were required for Councilors.  While conferences/LLX were virtual, we were able to try new approaches such as online voting and technology for our work.  Now that we are moving forward to whatever may be our future, then we will need to figure how to not only engage with each other but also how do we engage and interact with our members?  Conferences and meetings are one of the most important venues in which we have opportunities to listen to and provide information for members.  And of course, learn and develop as individuals.

    The full policy is below that notes the registration requirements.

    A.7.4.5 Registration at Conferences and Midwinter Meetings (Old Number 7.4.5)

    ALA members may attend general membership and council meetings, whenever and wherever held, by showing either a conference badge for the day of the meeting or a current membership card. Registration badges shall be shown for admission to all other meetings.

    Registration at Annual Conferences and Midwinter Meetings is required of all those attending all other meetings of the Association, its units, committees, etc., except as specifically waived by action of the Executive Board.



    ------------------------------
    Maggie Farrell
    ALA Treasurer
    Dean of Libraries
    University of Nevada, Las Vegas
    maggie.farrell@unlv.edu
    ------------------------------



  • 9.  RE: Rules & Guidelines for ALA Hybrid Council Meetings

    Posted May 02, 2022 08:13 AM

    Thank you Maggie. I certainly defer to your better knowledge of ALA and past practice.  Sometimes it is hard for newer Councilors to understand where our policies (and past practices) come from.  I've re-read the relevant sections of the Policy Manual and can't find a requirement that Councilors must register for conference in order to attend Council.  The first paragraph in 7.4.5 says a membership card is sufficient for general membership and Council meetings.  In the second paragraph the use of 'other meetings' seems to exempt the previously referenced general membership and Council meetings.  Is there somewhere else in the Policy Manual that speaks to this issue?  I can see Councilors who do not register being denied access to ALA housing during a conference but I don't see how the policy prohibits them from attending Council without registration.

    I find great value in attending in-person ALA conferences and encourage all who can to attend.  I have been fortunate in having employers who supported my attendance and wish that all employers understood the value of in-person conferences.  But I have learned over the last 3 years that finances, while significant, are not the only barrier to attendance.  I hope we continue to look for ways to break down all barriers. 

    Now that Council meets throughout the year -- not just at Annual and LibLearnX -- it seems unfair to require Councilors to pay to attend some Council meetings but not to attend others.  In any case, as this discussion illustrates, there can be honest confusion about what our policy actually does say.

    Eileen

    --  Eileen M. Palmer Executive Director Libraries of Middlesex Automation Consortium NJLA Chapter Councilor to the ALA  27 Mayfield Ave. Edison, NJ 08837 (732) 750-2525 ext. 103 (732) 225-0910 (fax) empalmer@lmxac.org
    On 4/29/2022 9:06 PM, Maggie Farrell via ALA Connect wrote:
    0100018078012fcb-6ed8bc58-847a-4345-b05a-ae19cfa204c0-000000@email.amazonses.com">
    Thank you for this discussion and the values of access and equity.  Prior to the pandemic, in-person attendance and conference registration were...
    American Library Association

    ALA Council

    Post New Message
    Re: Rules & Guidelines for ALA Hybrid Council Meetings
    Email a reply to the discussion Send a private message via email
    Apr 29, 2022 8:06 PM
    Maggie Farrell

    Thank you for this discussion and the values of access and equity.  Prior to the pandemic, in-person attendance and conference registration were required for Councilors.  While conferences/LLX were virtual, we were able to try new approaches such as online voting and technology for our work.  Now that we are moving forward to whatever may be our future, then we will need to figure how to not only engage with each other but also how do we engage and interact with our members?  Conferences and meetings are one of the most important venues in which we have opportunities to listen to and provide information for members.  And of course, learn and develop as individuals.

    The full policy is below that notes the registration requirements.

    A.7.4.5 Registration at Conferences and Midwinter Meetings (Old Number 7.4.5)

    ALA members may attend general membership and council meetings, whenever and wherever held, by showing either a conference badge for the day of the meeting or a current membership card. Registration badges shall be shown for admission to all other meetings.

    Registration at Annual Conferences and Midwinter Meetings is required of all those attending all other meetings of the Association, its units, committees, etc., except as specifically waived by action of the Executive Board.



    ------------------------------
    Maggie Farrell
    ALA Treasurer
    Dean of Libraries
    University of Nevada, Las Vegas
    maggie.farrell@unlv.edu
    ------------------------------
      Forward  




     
    You are subscribed to "ALA Council" as empalmer@lmxac.org. To change your subscriptions, go to My Subscriptions. To unsubscribe from this community discussion, go to Unsubscribe.



    Original Message:
    Sent: 4/29/2022 9:06:00 PM
    From: Maggie Farrell
    Subject: RE: Rules & Guidelines for ALA Hybrid Council Meetings

    Thank you for this discussion and the values of access and equity.  Prior to the pandemic, in-person attendance and conference registration were required for Councilors.  While conferences/LLX were virtual, we were able to try new approaches such as online voting and technology for our work.  Now that we are moving forward to whatever may be our future, then we will need to figure how to not only engage with each other but also how do we engage and interact with our members?  Conferences and meetings are one of the most important venues in which we have opportunities to listen to and provide information for members.  And of course, learn and develop as individuals.

    The full policy is below that notes the registration requirements.

    A.7.4.5 Registration at Conferences and Midwinter Meetings (Old Number 7.4.5)

    ALA members may attend general membership and council meetings, whenever and wherever held, by showing either a conference badge for the day of the meeting or a current membership card. Registration badges shall be shown for admission to all other meetings.

    Registration at Annual Conferences and Midwinter Meetings is required of all those attending all other meetings of the Association, its units, committees, etc., except as specifically waived by action of the Executive Board.



    ------------------------------
    Maggie Farrell
    ALA Treasurer
    Dean of Libraries
    University of Nevada, Las Vegas
    maggie.farrell@unlv.edu
    ------------------------------

    Original Message:
    Sent: Apr 29, 2022 10:44 AM
    From: Jessamyn West
    Subject: Rules & Guidelines for ALA Hybrid Council Meetings

    > Given that Council members are members of the Association I don't understand how requiring registration
    > to attend Council meetings is not a violation of our existing policy?

    I was confused too by the seeming conflict between the new Rules & Guidelines and ALA Policy. I saw President Wong's statement about making sure Councilors followed the policy (which I went and read) but this seems to conflict with it.

    ------------------------------
    Jessamyn West
    Chapter Councilor - Vermont
    she/her

    Original Message:
    Sent: Apr 29, 2022 07:44 AM
    From: Eileen Palmer
    Subject: Rules & Guidelines for ALA Hybrid Council Meetings

    Thank you Jessamyn for raising these concerns.  I find several of these rules, and the overall tone of the document, problematic -- but I agree that the registration requirement is especially troublesome.   I would be happy to join you in working on alternatives for consideration.   I also think that requiring registration to participate in Council/Membership meetings is a policy issue not a rules issue and I do not recall the issue coming to Council.   Did I miss something?

    The ALA Policy Manual states (emphasis mine):
    A.7.4.5 Registration at Conferences and Midwinter Meetings (Old Number 7.4.5)
    ALA members may attend general membership and council meetings, whenever and wherever held, by showing either a conference badge for the day of the meeting or a current membership card. Registration badges shall be shown for admission to all other meetings.

    Given that Council members are members of the Association I don't understand how requiring registration to attend Council meetings is not a violation of our existing policy?

    Eileen


    ------------------------------
    Eileen M. Palmer
    Executive Director
    LMxAC Libraries of Middlesex
    NJLA Chapter Councilor
    empalmer@lmxac.org

    Original Message:
    Sent: Apr 28, 2022 08:20 PM
    From: Jessamyn West
    Subject: Rules & Guidelines for ALA Hybrid Council Meetings

    Thanks for this Marsha -- I'm concerned about the new rule about meeting attendance. The new rules read...

    Virtual Attendees must register for the ALA Conference Digital Experience and Councilors are encouraged to be in attendance at least 15 minutes prior to the start of each Council meeting to help confirm quorum.

    and

    In-person Attendees must register for the ALA Conference

    In the past, the Membership Meetings and Council Meetings were open to anyone who was an ALA member or who had an exhibits pass, and those people did not have to register for the conference. This change is substantial in terms of potential costs to people who want to be involved in governance via the Membership Meeting or Council but who would not otherwise be attending.

    I believe this is a step backwards in ALA's DEI work by creating a cost barrier to participating in ALA governance and I'm dismayed to see it as a newly created rule I do appreciate and respect that ALA has real money concerns generally and doing a hybrid conference comes with associated costs, but I do not think that this is the way forward to encourage participation and attendance at Membership/Council meetings. If there are others who feel like I do, maybe we can change this rule back to the way it was previously to encourage participation while at the same time helping ALA find a way forward dealing with its money issues.

    ------------------------------
    Jessamyn West
    Chapter Councilor - Vermont
    she/her

    Original Message:
    Sent: Apr 28, 2022 05:29 PM
    From: Marsha P. Burgess
    Subject: Rules & Guidelines for ALA Hybrid Council Meetings

    This message is being sent on behalf of ALA President, Patty Wong

    Dear Councilors,

    The ALA Executive Board approved the "Rules & Guidelines for ALA Hybrid Council Meetings" (ALA CD#5.2, attached) for the 2022 Annual Conference in Washington, DC. Please review in advance of the practice session that will be held at the beginning of June, date and time will be announced.  The rules will be for adoption for all hybrid Council meetings. When adopted these rules will govern the conduct of the meeting.  Council agendas and documents will be uploaded to the website and ALA Connect in advance of the meetings.

    Councilors participating in person or virtually must register for the 2022 Annual Conference, please visit: https://2022.alaannual.org/. And, for those unable to join us in Washington, DC, please register for the Digital Experience: https://2022.alaannual.org/digital-experience

    A complete list of Governance Meetings can be found, here: https://www.ala.org/aboutala/ala-governance-meetings.



    ------------------------------
    Marsha P. Burgess
    Council Secretariat
    American Library Association
    mburgess@ala.org
    (312) 280-3204
    ------------------------------


  • 10.  RE: Rules & Guidelines for ALA Hybrid Council Meetings

    Posted May 02, 2022 08:52 AM
    I am rather perplexed that we are having this discussion about registration.  Prior to the pandemic, no one questioned whether councilors should register for an ALA Conference or Midwinter meeting.  I think that it's premature to assume that Council will continue to meet virtually between LibLearnX and Annual.  During the pandemic we adapted to the extraordinary circumstances in order to accomplish the work of the association.  It was never my understanding that this would become standard procedure.  The same goes for  the hybrid arrangement for the council meetings at Annual.   The ability for councilors to attend the meetings at Annual virtually is a special accommodation and an experiment to see how feasible this arrangement is.  I do not believe that it should be interpreted as the new normal going forward.

    I also find it odd that councilors are balking at the prospect of paying to attend an ALA conference.  As officers of the association, we should be doing all that we can to support ALA.

    ------------------------------
    John DeSantis
    Interim Head of Metadata Services
    Dartmouth College
    Hanover, NH
    he/him/his
    ------------------------------



  • 11.  RE: Rules & Guidelines for ALA Hybrid Council Meetings

    Posted May 02, 2022 09:18 AM
    This statement shows a lack of awareness around privilege and it is appalling. It assumes that councilors are more advanced in their careers, are earning beyond livable wages, and lack barriers to participation in ALA. I am a single mom with a mental illness that can often be debilitating.  A few months ago when I was very ill a "rule" like this would have kept me from participating in Council. I am extremely lucky that my dean is covering my trip to DC and I hope to maintain my health enough to participate in-person. I would have no way to "support" ALA if it wasn't for my dean being highly involved in ALA and willing to send me. 

    If we want to work towards a social justice praxis in ALA, then we have to begin looking at privilege and erasing barriers. We need Council representation of library paraprofessionals and support staff. We need representation of rural and school library workers. We need to have representation and offer ways of meaningful and engaged participation for members experiencing financial hardships, disabilities, childcare cost and availability, and systemic racism, classism, homophobia, etc.... 


    ------------------------------
    Amanda Roper
    Adult Services Librarian
    Chattanooga Gas
    She/Her/Hers
    ------------------------------



  • 12.  RE: Rules & Guidelines for ALA Hybrid Council Meetings

    Posted May 02, 2022 09:42 AM
    I am inclined to agree with John DeSantis when he says, "Prior to the pandemic, no one questioned whether councilors should register for an ALA Conference or Midwinter meeting.  I think that it's premature to assume that Council will continue to meet virtually between LibLearnX and Annual.  During the pandemic we adapted to the extraordinary circumstances in order to accomplish the work of the association.  It was never my understanding that this would become standard procedure."

    While I am a first-year Chapter Councilor, I have attended Council sessions as a general ALA member as a registered attendee at ALA Conference. I assumed waiving of the registration requirement was a temporary response to the pandemic.  While hosting hybrid meetings was a recent necessity, it may not be something the majority wants to continue moving forward. 

    Lisa Scroggins, Executive Director
    Natrona County Public Library
    Casper, Wyoming



    ------------------------------
    Lisa Scroggins
    Library Director
    1963
    ------------------------------



  • 13.  RE: Rules & Guidelines for ALA Hybrid Council Meetings

    Posted May 02, 2022 12:17 PM

    There was certainly a rhythm to the Council meetings when they were only twice a year, but the lack of meetings in between made us barely functional as the speed of association life increased. I cannot imagine that Council will be at all nimble or functional if wee try to return to meeting for 10-ish hours over three days twice a year. Meeting virtually very other month or every quarter for 2-3 hours makes much more sense, and allows issues to be considered as they arise, as well as to circle back to issues raised and appropriately referred to one or more committees.

     

    Additionally, if we are trying to make Council participation more inclusive of all our members, we need to be more respectful of time, money and travel constraints. Blocking out 3-4 days for travel to a conference requires a level of privilege not all librarians have; those same librarians may much more easily be able to find 2 hours periodically through the year. We want Council to represent the diversity that is ALA; let's put that intention into action!

     

    Dorcas Hand

    Texas Chapter Councilor

    Retired School Librarian

    Current Advocate for School librarians and for Intellectual Freedom






  • 14.  RE: Rules & Guidelines for ALA Hybrid Council Meetings

    Posted May 02, 2022 09:21 PM
    > if we are trying to make Council participation more inclusive of all our members, we need to be more respectful of time, money and travel constraints.
    > Blocking out 3-4 days for travel to a conference requires a level of privilege not all librarians have; those same librarians may
    > much more easily be able to find 2 hours periodically through the year.
    Well said. I also think this is true for being respectful of the times at which we have our meetings. Any of our colleagues from the West Coast or Alaska are going to have meetings which are very early in the morning or (for Hawaii) truly in the middle of the night. I think equity and inclusion mean meeting times which are during reasonable working hours for all of our American (at least) members.


    ------------------------------
    Jessamyn West
    Chapter Councilor - Vermont
    she/her
    ------------------------------



  • 15.  RE: Rules & Guidelines for ALA Hybrid Council Meetings

    Posted May 02, 2022 09:51 AM
    I have a tight schedule today so I'll try to keep this short. But let's talk about why going back to the way things used to be is a bad idea. 

    1. Time: If we have learned nothing from the last few years, I feel like we should have learned that trying to cram a year's worth of business into two meetings a year really isn't working. Council meetings frequently don't accomplish all the things they're supposed to, debate is stifled because of a lack of time, and people are missing out on a large part of the actual conference to attend meetings. Meeting more frequently through the year and using both virtual and hybrid meetings allows more business to get done in a timely manner. 

    2. Money: Fun fact, I am paying out of pocket to attend Annual for my final session as a councilor. I am able to afford this solely because people I love keep dying and leaving me money. This is not a feasible long term financial plan for affording participation in my professional organizations. Saying that we should return to the old model implies that only councilors of a certain financial standing should have a voice in the governance meetings. This is bad. 

    3. Health: We're in a pandemic. We're going to continue to be in some stage of a pandemic for a really long time probably. Telling people they only get to participate if they're healthy enough to do so and healthy enough to travel DURING A PANDEMIC again, is implying that we only want a certain kind of person to be eligible to a councilor. This is also bad. 

    4. It wasn't working before: I don't know if anyone has noticed, but ALA has lost a lot of members over the last 5-10 years. Now, maybe I'm wrong, but have we considered that perhaps going back to the what we were doing while we were hemorrhaging members is perhaps not the most logical of choices? Members have been saying for years that they're unhappy with how things have been and the use of virtual and hybrid meetings addresses some of those concerns. We need to keep doing them. 

    5. I'm just tired: I mean seriously, I feel like we keep banging our head against the wall with this but support is not supposed to be a one way street. And if it makes me a bad councilor because I don't want to have to pay virtual registration at a conference that I can't attend except for council meetings, well then I guess I'm a bad councilor. ALA should be bending over backwards to make conference and council meetings accessible and affordable for councilors. Not throwing up more barriers because we're still paying for the financial mistakes that were made. 

    6. Librarianship isn't just ALA members: I don't know why this seems to be such a weird concept, but ALA and ALA governance should be doing work to support and improve the whole of librarianship, not just the librarianship of those who can afford membership. Every time we put financial barriers in place for participation, we're shutting off more and more of library world that we should be supporting. It's bad. 

    We need to be moving forward and making this more accessible, not less. 





  • 16.  RE: Rules & Guidelines for ALA Hybrid Council Meetings

    Posted May 02, 2022 10:57 AM
    Natalie,

    First I want to say I'm sorry for all the losses that you have had to experience. Secondly, I agree with you wholeheartedly. Echoing Amanda, registering and attending conferences in person is a privilege that has only become more apparent with the pandemic. Yes, we agreed to be a part of Council but stating that registration is a requirement in order to fulfill your ALA Councilor duties is like forcing those of us with limited means to move mountains or risk going into debt.

    I was relieved when I found out LibLearnX was going to be virtual. My household income was cut in half due to the pandemic, forcing me to make personal and professional decisions that make traveling difficult, especially as a parent of small children. I appreciated the virtual meetings which allowed me to be home and not have to scramble for childcare. I fully support multiple virtual meetings, especially with the restructuring of ALA governance and all the proposed changes that will be taking place. This cannot be done in the expected timeline without meeting more than twice a year in person. It excludes so many of us that don't have the luxury of financial means or administrative approval. If I have to attend our next January meeting in person, that means either taking my children out of school to drive them the 4-5 hours to a grandparent's house (if the weather allows for it), or for my husband to take off work, costing us income that is much needed, in addition to the travel and lodging expenses the conference requires.

    The pandemic isn't over. We may not be on lockdown, but we cannot go back to the way things were. We've had several meetings discussing how the way things were have not been effective. If we want to create change so every voice is heard, affordability and accessibility is key. Budgets are being cut left and right and if I'm put in a position where it's between registering for a conference or having enough food to feed my family until the next paycheck comes in (which is not outside the realm of possibility), then it's no contest. I love being a librarian and the opportunities I have been given in this profession. I have loved my conference experiences and am looking forward to hopefully being able to attend more, but there are limits to what a person can (and should) do.

    ------------------------------
    Heather VanDyne
    Online Learning Librarian
    Fort Hays State University
    She/Her/Hers
    ------------------------------



  • 17.  RE: Rules & Guidelines for ALA Hybrid Council Meetings

    Posted May 02, 2022 11:22 AM

    I too am concerned with the barriers to participation that mandatory conference registration causes. I do not believe that the governance of the association should be tied directly to conferences as we move into the future of ALA. We have seen that a virtual council session model can be very successful and increases inclusion and participation. As seen from the discussion thread, there are many factors that contribute to a councilor's ability to attend conference. Yes, everyone who wants to attend conference for the highly beneficial learning, networking, and professional support that takes place there (both in person and virtual) should have to register to do so. But, I don't believe our current reality requires us to tie governance and conference together.

     

    Katie Cerqua

    Councilor at Large






  • 18.  RE: Rules & Guidelines for ALA Hybrid Council Meetings

    Posted Apr 30, 2022 04:41 PM
    I want to thank Jessamyn for bringing this up again - and I want to support my colleagues who have raised their concerns with these revised rules.

    For me, this also connects with Ann's comments about changes needing to be made to Forum. I have long felt the conversation that happens at Forum would be better had in Council meetings - even when we do a good job of not discussing or debating a topic, there is often crucial and useful background shared at Forum that those not in attendance miss. All of this discussion should be in one place, and we should ensure our Council meetings are scheduled with enough time to accommodate that conversation. That means Council meetings have to be more frequent and/or longer than they are currently, and, if they are more frequent, that I would for some reason be required to pay additional fees, essentially, to participate in some, but not all, our meetings.

    If we are truly committed to equity, we need to be reducing, not increasing, barriers to participation in governance and discussion. Longer Council meetings means even less opportunity to participate in other conference activities, and less value from the cost of my conference registration. Council's Tuesday morning meetings means I have to stay longer than I might if I were just at the conference. With hybrid options, there may be many reasons for participating virtually in Council meetings, and we should not assume Councilors doing so have the ability or capacity to take part in a virtual conference. Requiring my registration at a conference I may not be able to take part in feels a little like a poll tax - I have to pay to play.

    Especially in light of the crucial votes on Council's size, representation, and mandate happening at June's meetings, we should be striving to have as many Councilors able to participate as possible, whether in person or virtually. We're still in experimental mode; we don't know what it will be like to have a hybrid Council, and it seems premature to suddenly establish new rules. Reviewing and revising the rules pertaining to Council attendance and will most likely have to be done after we complete the TAG process - why wouldn't we wait until that has been decided, even if it is to recommit to past practice?





  • 19.  RE: Rules & Guidelines for ALA Hybrid Council Meetings

    Posted Apr 30, 2022 04:53 PM

    Yes, Stephanie

    We do need to reduce the barriers and this year especially, that is of concern. So much is in flux from pandemic recovery, ongoing travel restrictions by employers or for personal health reasons, to imminent changes in the Council and further governance structures. The time commitment by Councilors is intense, even without the financial one. Virtual attendance is one element of pandemic survival that I hope will remain as an element of encouraging member engagement.

     

    Are ALA members who are not attending conference allowed/encouraged to attend Council meetings virtually without paying conference registration? If yes, then Councilors should be as well. Virtual attendees would have no other benefits of conference attendance, but are taking the time and energy to be engaged members of ALA. I fully realize the loss of their conference registration fees is a hit to the conference bottom line, but for this confused year, I would think it a worthwhile element of member and Councilor engagement.

     

    I look forward to seeing everyone in person on the Council floor – but for those unable to attend, I hope we can welcome them virtually without conference registration.

     

    Dorcas Hand

    Texas Chapter Councilor

    School Library and Intellectual Freedom Advocate

    Houston TX






  • 20.  RE: Rules & Guidelines for ALA Hybrid Council Meetings

    Posted May 04, 2022 12:28 PM
    Dear Councilors:

    Thank you  all for the engagement and weighing in on Council participation and conference registration.  I wanted to give you some thoughts that framed the Board's decision to determine the considerations in coming up with  these rules. There was significant conversation on trying to achieve a balance on the side of equity and recognizing and valuing the work and time of Council and the entire governing body. The volunteerism and support of Council and the impact of those contributions are so appreciated.  As the Board we also are cognizant of the fiscal needs of the organization.  Historically yes, there has been an expectation of Council and the Board's engagement with our members at Conference - indeed the Bylaws reflect those expectations.  There is no doubt that things have changed for us with the pandemic, and perhaps a hybrid environment is the wave of the future.  So far there are about 118 Council members that are registered and coming in person and about 14 that are coming hybrid and have registered with that discounted rate to give us some optics about this.  This is new territory for all of us.  The Board wanted to encourage participation, knowing that some may have difficulty in coming but still wanting to participate.  And maybe we move a little to a stronger hybrid model and different kinds of considerations of costs.  I wanted to share the background in considerations.  Council can make changes to the rules, and yes, that means that one has to be present and participating, but it certainly is possible.  Know that your concerns are heard and are part of  our ongoing considerations and decision making  and we hope that conversation can be done with you in a more open format.

    The ongoing conversation about longer meetings, better agenda building and meeting more frequently are so encouraging about how to make Council stronger and more effective and impactful no matter whether policy or advisory.  The resolutions passed focusing on fine tuning our responsibility as a governing body to create stronger cultural norms of effectiveness and a body of knowledge is incredibly powerful and the Council of the future.

    We look forward to your ongoing ideas and discourse on our growth together to create equity  - and that may take many steps - as we also focus on the fiscal and structural health of ALA together.

    Patty

    ------------------------------
    Patty Wong
    President, American Library Association
    personal cell (530) 848-8768
    personal email: pattywong61@comcast.net
    She/her/hers
    ------------------------------