ACRL RBMS Bibliographic Standards Committee Rare Books and Manuscripts Section

Poll: Do you approve of the formation of a Controlled Vocabularies Editorial Group with the attached charge?

  • 1.  Poll: Do you approve of the formation of a Controlled Vocabularies Editorial Group with the attached charge?

    Posted Jul 25, 2014 05:02 PM
      |   view attached

    Attachment(s)



  • 2.  RE: Poll: Do you approve of the formation of a Controlled Vocabularies Editorial Group with the attached charge?

    Posted Jul 29, 2014 08:41 AM

    The membership section states that the co-editors are to be members of BSC & PubCom. That will make coordinating terms even harder. Do we mean that the co-editors are to be members of the respective committees at the time of appointment, but they don't need to hold membership in the originating committees the entire time they are co-editors?



  • 3.  RE: Poll: Do you approve of the formation of a Controlled Vocabularies Editorial Group with the attached charge?

    Posted Jul 29, 2014 04:12 PM

    I'd like to propose some friendly amendments to the charge:

    --Change "The group will develop and maintain content and access of ..." to "The group will develop and maintain content of and access to ..."

    --Change "The group will be co-edited" to "The group will be co-chaired by two editors,"

    --Change "The appointments will be new ..." to "Each editor's appointment will be a new ..."

    Also, I suggest adding a sentence about the other members of the group, to clarify whether or not they need to be members of BSC, and how they're appointed.



  • 4.  RE: Poll: Do you approve of the formation of a Controlled Vocabularies Editorial Group with the attached charge?

    Posted Aug 01, 2014 07:50 AM
    Jul 25 2014 6:14PM Nancy Lorimer: Yes, I approve
    Jul 25 2014 6:52PM Jane Carpenter: Yes, I approve
    Jul 27 2014 10:45AM Audrey Pearson: Yes, I approve
    Jul 28 2014 7:41AM Michelle Mascaro: Yes, I approve
    Jul 28 2014 9:05AM Allison O'Dell: Yes, I approve
    Jul 28 2014 9:38AM Catherine Uecker: Yes, I approve
    Jul 28 2014 11:13AM Christine DeZelar-Tiedman: Yes, I approve
    Jul 28 2014 11:35AM Valerie Buck: Yes, I approve
    Jul 28 2014 12:02PM Linda Isaac: Yes, I approve
    Jul 29 2014 8:54AM Lori Dekydtspotter: Yes, I approve
    Jul 29 2014 10:05AM Matthew Haugen: Yes, I approve
    Aug 1 2014 8:49AM Ellen Cordes: Yes, I approve